We Don't Need No Age Segregation
11.10.10, 9:24am Comments (3)

My teenaged son just spent the day with middle-aged guys he met online. Sound scary?

Let me back up. Before he could drive, my son earned enough money shoveling out horse stalls to buy a 1973 Opel GT. Or what was left of one.

The car sits out back in a dark barn, its classic little outline like a rough sketch waiting for functional automotive details to be filled in again. He is restoring it himself. But he’s not alone. He’s in touch with an online community of automotive enthusiasts from around the world. They eagerly share experiences and resources on forums. They also boast, complain and talk about their interests just as any friends do.

My son and his father have met some of these folks at auto meets, car shows and rallies. When my son discovered an Opel club not far from our family farm he was invited to join. Today he and his older brother drove out for a day-long gathering. Although my boys were the youngest by decades they enjoyed an open-hearted welcome.

Yes, I realize there are significant concerns about teens talking online with adults, let alone meeting them. I try to keep those concerns in perspective. Studies of online behavior by youth indicate the biggest risk they face is peer harassment, not sexual predation. Today’s young people are much more overprotected than previous generations even though violence against kids has markedly decreased and the overall crime rate continues to plummet. Overly cautious, restrictive parenting practices actually inhibit a teen’s growth toward maturity and responsibility. So I watch, ask questions and recognize that my son benefits from online friends and mentors.

It’s a pivotal coming of age experience to be accepted by elders one admires. Until that time it’s hard to feel like an adult. These experiences are frequently depicted in movies, but children and teens in our culture are almost entirely segregated from meaningful and regular involvement with adults.

These days kids spend their formative years with age mates in day care, school, sports and other activities. So their adult role models are largely those whose main function is to manage children. This subverts the way youth have learned and matured throughout human history. Children are drawn to watch, imitate and gain useful skills. They want to see how people they admire handle a crisis, build a business, compose music, repair a car and fall in love. Separate kids from purposeful, interesting interaction with adults and they have little to guide them other than their peers and the entertainment industry. That’s because our species learns by example. Ask any child development expert, neuroscientist or great grandparent.

There are plenty of educational initiatives to bridge this gap, particularly for teens. These programs connect students with mentors or bring community members into schools to talk about their careers. While these efforts are admirable, such stopgap measures aren’t the way young people learn best. They need to spend appreciable time with people of all ages—observing, conversing and taking on responsibility. Real responsibilities, real relationships.

Because my kids are homeschooled they’ve have more opportunities (and a lot more time) to hang out with interesting adults. My daughter volunteers for hours each week alongside a woman who rehabilitates birds of prey. Another of my sons played bagpipes for years with an 80- something gent who once served as a Pipe Major for Scotland’s Black Watch. The age range of my kids’ friends spans decades. Natural mentors such as these are a rich source of authentic experience. And they’re in every community. It’s not hard to find them.

Along with other homeschooling families, my kids have also taken a close look at the workaday adult world. The owner of a steel drum company explained the history and science of drum-making, talked about the rewards and risks of entrepreneurship, then encouraged us to play the drums displayed there. An engineer took us through his testing facility and showed us how materials are developed for the space program. We’ve spent days with potters, woodworkers, architects, chemists, archeologists, stagehands, chefs, paramedics and others.

People rarely turn us down when we request the chance to learn from them. Perhaps the desire to pass along wisdom and experience to the next generation is encoded in our genes. Age segregation goes both ways--adults are also separated from most youth in our society. After an afternoon together we’ve gotten the same feedback again and again. These adults say they had no idea the work they do would be so interesting to kids. They marvel at the questions asked, observations made and ideas proffered by youth that the media portrays as disaffected or worse. They shake hands with young people who a few hours ago were strangers and say, “Come back in a few years, I’d like to have you intern here,” or “We could use an engineer who thinks the way you do. Think about going into the field,” or “Thanks for coming. I’ve never had this much fun at work.”

So today my teenaged son hung out with fellow Opel aficionados. They trust he will drive his car out of the dark barn and into the sunlight soon. It will be a shared accomplishment, the kind of thing that happens all the time when young people aren’t separated from the wider community.

Rate this article

Your rating: None Average: 5 (3 votes)

Comments

Good article. When I was a young teenager, my stepmom introduced me to a co-worker's husband who shared my interest of guitars and comic books. She dropped me off at his house that day and we had a good time playing guitar and going to the comic book store. It was one of the first (and only) times in my early teenage years that I can remember an adult treating me like an equal.

When I first started to read this I was appalled, maybe because my kids are so much younger that I can't imagine them having friendships with anyone out of diapers.

But then, thinking about what this really said (and taking into account JB's comment) I realized that when I was a kid adults either told me what to do all the time or acted like they were kids themselves. I had no role models of who to be or how to be except what I didn't want to be. It was that way through high school and college my first few jobs---adults I didn't respect.

Except for one neighbor lady. When I was a teen I thought of her as really old. I realize now she was probably in her late 40's or early 50's. She had a big loom in her living room and after work she'd come home, put on music and weave. She also had a big garden and gave away lots of her veggies. She laughed easily with that thick smoker's sort of cough-laugh. I'd go visit her, no reason, and she'd tell me to make myself some tea and we'd talk or just sit listening to music. I can't remember any real advice she gave me. But even now I summon her in my head as an example of a real grown up, a person who knows who she is. That's who I'd like to be for people younger than me. And I see now that people like that is who I'd like my kids to know when they're old enough to ring a neighbor's doorbell.

Great to hear about adults who gladly acted as natural mentors, even if only for a day. Those are authentic experiences that have staying power for teens.

I've tried to recall any such mentors I might have had. Only one person stands out. She was an older lady who lived around the corner from us. I met her one day when I was going door to door for some reason, maybe a petition drive. She invited me in and listened to my spiel. I didn't go on for long because I was mesmerized by what she was doing. She had finished baking her daughter's wedding cake and was assembling it, using small glass soda bottles to separate the layers. That she made the cake and much of the food astonished me, that she found time to talk to me when the wedding would take place the next day was even more astonishing. I'd never met such a capable woman. She rode her bike everywhere rather than drive, ran a small orchard and sold the apples, cut her grass with an old unpowered reel mower. Other women felt sorry for her or scorned her weather-worn appearance. She seemed too centered to care. I didn't take the opportunity to talk to her often but the example she set has stays with me.