Today's smartphone industry is controlled by giant tech companies with impenetrable black-box devices running proprietary software, who engage in patent lawsuits and baby-panda eating in their spare time. This last claim may not technically be true, but I figure it's election season, why can't I get in on the fun?
Many may hope for an alternative phone which offers more freedom for the user, more transparency and more adaptability. But a viable consumer option may be a long way off.
So far there has only been one option for a smartphone which is truly open and free (as in freedom) – the Openmoko project from 2008, which has now been reborn as Open Phoenux. Mine arrived a couple of weeks ago.
Not only does it run free software, but the hardware is also open source – the manual comes complete with board layouts and schematics for each of its parts.
Why would anyone want an open source phone in the first place? For the same price, you could get a shiny new iPhone.
First of all, the Open Phoenux is not meant to compete head-to-head with Apple and Samsung – not yet, anyway. It's not a phone built for the casual consumer. It is a phone by geeks, for geeks – a developmental playground to learn how a phone works, to write operating systems and other mobile software, to hook up to different devices, to run hacks and hobby projects. By keeping the hardware and development open, it means that the experience and improvements of the developers are shared with the commons, for anyone to use and build upon. It makes it easier for people to develop new, unexpected uses for mobile technology. When a user has a better understanding of what's actually inside their phone, they might also start to think a little bit more about where everything came from. With open hardware, the components can easily be replaced and upgraded, making for longer smartphone lifecycles. Ever tried upgrading an iPhone's hardware? Apple have special proprietary screws just to keep you out of 'your' phone. They don't want you to be able to change the battery. They don't want you to understand why your phone isn't working, they just want you to buy a new one. At least some people are trying to fight this tendency:
My Open Phoenux came with Linux pre-installed, but in order to actually make calls you need to install a smartphone operating system. I settled on QtMoko as it was said to be the easiest to get started. I realised this was going to be a technical challenge for someone who has only been using free software for a couple of months, and had never even partitioned a hard drive, but I was prepared to be patient, to be thorough, and above all to be very, very careful.
I checked and double-checked my way through the instructions: Card formatted correctly! QtMoko prepared in the right way! Battery inserted! Device turned on! Bootloader! This is all going remarkably well, I thought. My internal high-fives quietly disappeared when I realised the phone had stopped responding.
Replacing the battery did nothing. Threatening it back to life with a fierce shake of my fist may have been somewhat optimistic. Shaking two fists proved more therapeutic, though yielded similar results.
Somewhere along the line I must have taken a wrong turn. In my hand I held more technology than all the Apollo missions combined, and I had turned it into something with all the computing power of a moon rock.
I needed help. As with any open source project, the place to turn is the community itself.
Those who responded on the mailing list managed to work out the problem, and I can proudly say that my phone did not die in vain – they have now fixed the installation package and improved the documentation to stop anyone else following my own wobbly footsteps to oblivion.
Meanwhile I must wait until I can get my hands on the right kind of cable to be able to reanimate my phone and make that long-awaited first call. Until then I'm left coming up with new uses for a temporarily-dead open source smartphone around the house:
Any other ideas?
I'll keep you posted on my progress resuscitating this Open Phoenux, and if you're interested in this area, keep an eye on developments with the free software operating system Firefox OS, and also the Fairphone initiative to bring more transparency, choice and accountability to phone production.
UPDATE: IT'S ALIVE! ALIIIVE!
I mean, it's not necessarily functional yet, but at least it turns on..
Rate this article
- Kicking off a Year of Open Source Everything
- Open Tech Forever Challenges Proprietary Innovation
- This Week in Sharing: Creative Destruction!
- 5 Burning Man Projects Changing the Real World
- How to Build a Vibrant Open Source Community
- Diaspora: A New Beginning or a Crowdfunding Cautionary Tale?
- Logic Shrink: A Game to Bring Logic Back into Political Rhetoric
- Keeps Your Whites Whiter and Your Skin Itchier
- How Public is Your Transport?
- Serve Cold, with a Heated Licensing Discussion