Earth Day has zero appeal for me. Don’t get me wrong, I'm all for saving the earth. That's one of the reasons I help found Shareable. And I recognize the dramatic positive changes Earth Day catalyzed long ago.
It’s just that…
Back in 2000, when I lived in DC, I was invited to hang out back stage at the Earth Day concert on the Mall. This was supposed to be a cool thing, to mingle with all the celebrities. The thing I remember most is a certain celebrity that sashayed by our tent. I was stunned by the air of preciousness and contrivance that hung heavy like rank incense around her, and her bad plastic surgery. Truly bizarre.
Fact is, I was uncomfortable backstage. I didn’t want to talk to celebrities. I didn’t want to add to the intrusive crush of attention they likely feel all the time. It must be oppressive. Nor did I have any desire to play the role of worshipful fan. So I felt stifled. That atmosphere is the polar opposite of the peer sociality I seek, an atmosphere where everyone can speak freely.
Consider this. Celebrity culture directs our attention away from each other - and what we can accomplish together - toward icons carefully manufactured for our consumption, to stoke our desire, to stoke our consumption. Celebrities are gods in the pantheon of consumer culture. They play a leading role in the destruction of our civic life.
And Earth Day is a celebrity now. It’s a media event that asks us how we can be more green, when green has largely come to mean buying the right stuff. Moreover, when it's not being celebrated with concerts like the one on the Mall this year featuring Sting, then it's celebrated with token acts of environmentalism while the economic system that's destroying our planet doesn't miss a beat.
This economic system is cordoned off from citizens like a celebrity. It's coddled. It shoplifts. It has bodyguards. It's addicted not to coke, but to growth. It gets drunk and crashes not cars, but entire economies. We’re excluded from the political process to the degree that we have no more chance of having a real impact than of getting lunch with Lady Gaga.
With the crowds, celebrity worship, token acts, and all the ecofabulous crap being showcased, Earth Day reproduces consumer culture faithfully in all its boring glory. And in the process does little for, if not undermines, the citizenship needed to care for each other and the earth.
We should take what Al Gore said in his 2008 TED speech more seriously, “to solve the climate crisis, we have to solve the democracy crisis.”
This is the real inconvenient truth.
It’s inconvenient because it points to the root cause of environmental degradation – the exclusion of ordinary people from the political process and the spoils of their work. The inconvenient truth is that we can’t manage our natural resources for the long term without broadly shared decision making and access to resources. The inconvenient truth is that a sustainable world is only possible if it’s shareable.
But nobody seemed to take much note of that speech, impassioned as it was. I guess changing light bulbs is easier, though it leaves the truth in the dark.
This conundrum prompted me to do a search to see if there are any Earth Day voter registration drives today. Slim pickings, though in the top five results, I found one in Ohio, organized by Robert Wofter, where no one signed up to volunteer.
I salute you Robert Wofter. Today, you are my Earth Day hero, as lonely as you might be at your voter registration table.
Teaser image from Wikimedia Commons.
Rate this article
Comments
Very astute. The power of consumerism as a form of "engagement" is obvious, but the issue is that the "participation" that consumption represents is reactive (rather than PROactive) and has the appearance of being palliative while only deepening the actual pathology.
We need events and activities that make us feel like we belong, and are engaged. That part I feel good about.
But the conclusions that those activities raise need to be proactive, honest about the problems, and most of all, open to diverse public dialogue about what the problems and solutions might actually be.
Indeed it is true that this is a democracy problem more than an environment problem, at least in the U.S.
Thanks Josh for the thoughtful comment. It reminded me of a conversation I had with Ken White, Development Director of the Post Carbon Institute, at Design 4 Resilience.
He used to work for Common Cause, which advocates for things like campaign finance reform. He was told when he started as a fundraiser there that Common Cause is everyone's second cause. That's because when donors go to save the turtles, they eventually discover that they need to engage a political system that's rigged against the environment. Then they become donors to Common Cause.
Yup! I used to work at Common Cause too -- I interned there in college, and I still think that campaign finance reform is *the* issue to look at in politics. I've been dying to get Free Range involved with some campaign finance reform groups, 'cause their issues need some creative love.
This was a great article, Neal. Thanks for posting! :)
Melicopter is in the howwwwse! Yeah, I'm with you Melissa on campaign finance reform, it's a meta solution. And I extend the logic to any intervention that leads to systemic change. For instance, getting off of monopoly currency as much as possible, decentralizing our concentrated media system, repealing corporate personhood, all the way down to zoning laws that limit shared and mixed use. In other words, it's no good to address symptoms or just elect people who we think will do us better when the the conditions which produce dysfunction remain unchanged.
Wired did a piece which details how Earth Day used to be an extremely civic occasion:
http://www.wired.com/wiredscience/2010/04/earth-day-1970/
Very cool. This discussion has me thinking about what Shareable might do for Earth Day next year. A voter registration drive?
What else, any ideas how to make it a civic occasion again?
Related Articles
- Occupy as a New Societal Model & Ways To Improve It
- Crowdfunding Social Change
- Play a Game to Find Pathways Out of Poverty
- Time to Occupy the Calendar
- 5 Ways Sharing Can Help You Live A Low-Impact Life
- Participatory Budgeting Gains Steam in San Francisco
- Please Donate $10 to Shareable
- iPhone's Darkside Exposed by New Banned Game App
- Micro-Participation Connects Citizens to Their Governments
- At U.N. Happiness Summit, A Coal Pile in the Ballroom
Community Blog Posts
-
By Jay Cousins
-
By Nipun Mehta
-
By Rik Crevits
Recent comments
-
6 hours 31 min ago
-
20 hours 2 min ago
-
21 hours 48 min ago
-
1 day 57 min ago
-
1 day 2 hours ago



Great post, Neal!
The pinpoint: "the exclusion of ordinary people from the political process and the spoils of their work." *well* said.